Quick answer
Compare the local rules with the tenancy dates and itemized claims; ordinary wear and actual tenant damage differ.
Do now
Keep lease, deposit receipt, move-in/out photos, inspection notices, forwarding-address proof, and the deduction statement. Request a written explanation and consider the proper court route if unresolved.
Local note
NJ generally uses a 30-day return rule for covered tenancies; NY’s non-regulated-unit guide describes 14 days; DC uses a 45-day return-or-notice framework with further balance-return rules. Check exceptions.
Official sources
NJ DCA — Security Deposit Bulletin, NY Attorney General — Residential Tenants’ Rights Guide, DC OTA — Tenant Bill of Rights, September 25, 2026.